Mazdaspeed Forums

Mazdaspeed Forums (http://www.mazdaspeedforums.org/forum/)
-   Gen2 MS3 General Discussion (http://www.mazdaspeedforums.org/forum/f544/)
-   -   Scion FRS vs WRX vs MS3 (http://www.mazdaspeedforums.org/forum/f544/scion-frs-vs-wrx-vs-mazdaspeed-3-a-118403/)

CaptObvious75 07-10-2012 01:09 PM

My stockers are starting to crack between the threads! The fuck...

Sent from my Atrix

Easter Bunny 07-10-2012 01:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tokay444 (Post 1502099)
All season tires are just that. The worst possible option in all seasons.

Jack of all trades, master of none, not that i care, they are fine for what i need from the car 99% of the time, and if i want to go fast i have a bike.

breakfstincluded 07-10-2012 01:56 PM

i no has money to go through lots of tires frequently

it rains a lot here

what rubber i has get

Tokay444 07-10-2012 02:02 PM

Michelin super sports.

smurugby12 07-10-2012 03:56 PM

Someone should post this on ft86club.com's forum

BLK_MS3 07-10-2012 06:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SpdDemon89 (Post 1501637)




4 doors....thank you

awd......thank you

sedan or hatch.....thank you

straight line drag or track day you'll be a force to reckon......thank you

Depends on what you like, to me:

2 doors over 4 doors, just looks way better.
RWD over AWD if you can drive.
Coupe over hatch or sedan, again looks better.
Most average drivers will be quicker on a track in the FR-S/BR-Z as they seem to be very forgiving and easy to control.

breakfstincluded 07-10-2012 06:19 PM

I think there's a very fun factor in beating someone in a front wheel drive car.

Just my opinion but if you're the one driving out of your friends often, more than one guy getting out of a 2 door anything looks just slightly homo. Maybe a Father and younger son I can take.

But win if you just spend all week wine and dining with gf.

I think the CTS-V Wagon is the one I'd go for before the coupe and sedan.

http://www.roadandtrack.com/var/ezfl...port-wagon.jpg

I also like how the E36 M3 looks best in the rarer 4 door model.

Disregarding price, I think the GT86 looks pretty fun, for a noob like me, all NA 200hp would be plenty and probably give me more confidence on the track.

ztnedman1 07-10-2012 06:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Easter Bunny (Post 1501549)
Ditching the dunlops and going to continental dws all seasons was an upgrade on my pu.

Upgrade?! LOL I have some you can buy...

Worst tire ever. If the MS3 cam ewith gummy bear tires like that I would have never bought it. Do your self a favor and pass.

dsmluck 07-11-2012 12:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tokay444 (Post 1501746)
You're*
Smartass=natural predator of dumbass.

It's a coupé.
Not a roadster.

Awd no thank you.
Since when does the wrx have a strong tranny?

What record does wrx/sti have in stock form?


I already stated if they had put the tires on the other two cars, the speed would have come out on top, as it did when they were on stock tires with the frs.

The WRXs transmission since 2009 uses thicker legacy GT gears. While not "strong" it will hold 380- 400wtq as a daily driver. Hardly the old glass transmission.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tokay444 (Post 1501542)
V12's aren't even on par with the potenzas that came on the Genwon.

Bullshit. I went from the crap potenzas to the V12. Better turn in and lateral grip. Straightline grip was the same though.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Easter Bunny (Post 1501785)
I kind of agree with that statement, while the sidewall is pretty soft and the feel is nowhere near the same, I feel that I the compound is better, even in the high heat we have had recently to the point where I can corner faster.

I tracked my car with DWS's a few weeks back. Sidewall flex is bad and when they get heated they start to get greasy. Good all arounder for daily driving but I know I am giving up cornering performance for all weather capabilities.

spokelse 07-11-2012 01:44 AM

I just got an MS3, with the crap Dunlop sport tires, took it out for autocrossing and a track day already, (I'm one of those guys), jesus, its a great track car, autocross, not so much, the turbo bogs down unless you left foot break, which I hate doing, anyway, this car has amazing performance capabilities that have nothing to do with drag racing, putting a huge big turbo on it, etc, , for the money, there really isn't anything like this, yes you can get a dialed in rear wheel or all wheel drive, but really for far more money. The actual price you'll pay is far less than invoice, I got mine for 21.5, what else is even close to this?

Tokay444 07-11-2012 03:51 AM

Nothing.

dbrier 07-11-2012 05:54 AM

I agree about the performance for value.
The new Mustang GT and MS3 are the two best performance cars for the dollar on the market right now.

dsmluck 07-11-2012 07:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by spokelse (Post 1503069)
I just got an MS3, with the crap Dunlop sport tires, took it out for autocrossing and a track day already, (I'm one of those guys), jesus, its a great track car, autocross, not so much, the turbo bogs down unless you left foot break, which I hate doing, anyway, this car has amazing performance capabilities that have nothing to do with drag racing, putting a huge big turbo on it, etc, , for the money, there really isn't anything like this, yes you can get a dialed in rear wheel or all wheel drive, but really for far more money. The actual price you'll pay is far less than invoice, I got mine for 21.5, what else is even close to this?

The Cobalt SS/TC was and the new Focus ST will be a direct competitor. I agree with you that the cars fantastic capabilities really shine in the corners. 21.5k for a brand new MS3 is a borderline robbery. lol

slow k24 07-11-2012 03:49 PM

ive roll raced a few WRXs and beat them in my stock car vs there modded cars for the guy saying how great the WRX is in drag racing.

Design 07-11-2012 04:41 PM

I think there's another pretty compelling element in this test. On the FRS, diameter/weight aside, there was NO increase in cornering speed with a 20mm wider tire of the same compound. I've talked to many racers who swear by aspect-ratio-to-wheel-width over fitting the widest tire possible under the wells. And I think this community could benefit from that approach as well.

After driving several variants, I'm convinced that 225/40/18 on an 8-8.5" wheel is a match made in heaven for our cars.

Tokay444 07-11-2012 06:32 PM

But 235/40/18 is the closest thing to stock rollout diametre.

dsmluck 07-11-2012 07:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by slow k24 (Post 1504127)
ive roll raced a few WRXs and beat them in my stock car vs there modded cars for the guy saying how great the WRX is in drag racing.

Jesus fucking Christ. It never ends. You talk about drag racing and use an example of a highway roll race to prove your point. Don't you see how stupid that is?

x09MS3GT 07-11-2012 07:35 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by another 6cms6 (Post 1501131)
Sorry to inform you that the frs/brz isnt built for ultimate grip out of the box. You dont need grip to have fun and I think that is the premise of the car.

The rear stock ms3 suspension is not something I would wabt to be comparing anything to either.

Here, compare it to this

Is that a good rear suspension ? Tee Hee

breakfstincluded 07-11-2012 08:31 PM

http://wpc.556e.edgecastcdn.net/8055...vtaZ59_1_m.jpg


yeeeyyyaa netflix movie about wrx drag racing (:

Honestly, I didn't hate it.

Apparently we can do 10's in a subaru with a single parts trip to pep boys.

breakfstincluded 07-12-2012 11:44 AM

2013 Scion FR-S vs 2013 Hyundai Genesis Coupe 2.0T R-Spec : Car Reviews

I'd take the FRS vs the new 274hp gencoupe, despite price/power ratio.

I'd be very motivated to get on the track often.

Easter Bunny 07-12-2012 12:34 PM

Meh I'd take a used rx8 over both of them

Tokay444 07-12-2012 12:38 PM

I'd wait for something good to come out.

spokelse 07-12-2012 01:09 PM

I agree with the aspect ratio approach and think Mazda should be given credit here, they really made the new MS3 very much a driver's car, aggressive toe and camber, a more dialed in suspension compared to the previous generation, mostly in regard to compliance, and I guess they can be forgiven putting the dunlops on, they are serviceable for what I do, and after I shred them, I'm probably going with the Bridgestone's. Does anyone have other suggestions. I use the star specs on my neon acr and have had good autox results on it, but its a much lighter and lower powered car. And in terms of the FRS, etc, they are apparently quite well sorted for handling, probably an ultimate stock momentum car. I do know that the toyota/subaru differences are more about different flavors, etc, if you want to do A, then pick the Toyota/Scion, if you want to do more B then pick Subaru, etc

Tokay444 07-12-2012 03:41 PM

Apparently if you want more hp, pick the baru.
If you live in japan, pick the yot.
If you have a vagina, pick the scion.

breakfstincluded 07-12-2012 03:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tokay444 (Post 1505941)
Apparently if you want more hp, pick the baru.
If you live in japan, pick the yot.
If you have a vagina, pick the scion.

LOL

I bet there's a few owners cringing with their new vagina that are paying for express shipping for Toyota badges.

671 grains of reason 07-12-2012 04:52 PM

so from what i gather from this thread, nearly everyone only cares about drag racing. lulz.

damn fast and the furious generation.

:dance:

Tokay444 07-12-2012 04:55 PM

Nope. I'm a circuit racer. And my car is still faster then the rwd scion.

Nliiitend1 07-12-2012 05:28 PM

I think a lot of people are really "missing the point" of the new FR-S/FT86/BRZ.

It's not always about lap times and "the numbers."

It's about bringing a wonderfully balanced, low COG, RWD car to the masses. One that, while not the fastest thing around a racetrack, just might be one of the most fun to drive in such a manner, and isn't so high strung that most novices can't really extract most of what it has to offer without a ridiculous amount of seat time.

It's like the SV650 of cars. :)

Fatguy729 07-12-2012 09:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nliiitend1 (Post 1506111)
I think a lot of people are really "missing the point" of the new FR-S/FT86/BRZ.

It's not always about lap times and "the numbers."

It's about bringing a wonderfully balanced, low COG, RWD car to the masses. One that, while not the fastest thing around a racetrack, just might be one of the most fun to drive in such a manner, and isn't so high strung that most novices can't really extract most of what it has to offer without a ridiculous amount of seat time.

It's like the SV650 of cars. :)

I hate to say it, but that kinda sounds like a miata!

slow k24 07-12-2012 10:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dsmluck (Post 1504596)
Jesus fucking Christ. It never ends. You talk about drag racing and use an example of a highway roll race to prove your point. Don't you see how stupid that is?

we dont have any tracks near where i live and we did some dig runs too so we just race where we can

Quote:

Originally Posted by breakfstincluded (Post 1504781)
http://wpc.556e.edgecastcdn.net/8055...vtaZ59_1_m.jpg


yeeeyyyaa netflix movie about wrx drag racing (:

Honestly, I didn't hate it.

Apparently we can do 10's in a subaru with a single parts trip to pep boys.

as long as you no lift shift

NoTraction 07-13-2012 05:20 AM

I have driven all 3
If they ever came out with a turbo brz/frs sti variant etc. I'd choose that over the speed3.. But since its slow as balls the way it is now.. MS3 FTMFW!!!!! the wrx can eat 5 dicks

dsmluck 07-13-2012 09:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NoTraction (Post 1506789)
I have driven all 3
If they ever came out with a turbo brz/frs sti variant etc. I'd choose that over the speed3.. But since its slow as balls the way it is now.. MS3 FTMFW!!!!! the wrx can eat 5 dicks

Says the guy with more cosmetic mods than power mods. Who are you kidding you would feel right at home in an old riced out bug eye WRX.

NoTraction 07-18-2012 05:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dsmluck (Post 1508314)
Says the guy with more cosmetic mods than power mods. Who are you kidding you would feel right at home in an old riced out bug eye WRX.

I Don't have any cosmetic mods... Avatar's of my last speed3 that was fully bolted.. My current one is bone stock execpet for HID's cosmetically.. Nice try troll!:lame:

dsmluck 07-18-2012 06:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NoTraction (Post 1514132)
I Don't have any cosmetic mods... Avatar's of my last speed3 that was fully bolted.. My current one is bone stock execpet for HID's cosmetically.. Nice try troll!:lame:

Quote:

Cpe 75 Duro RMM, TIP, Gutted RP, 3000k HID headlights, Corksport SRI, Denso ITV22's
Sitting in Garage: 8k lows, 3k fogs, CS LED kit, My interior(stripped)
WANTED SOON: Raceland Coilz(worth it?)Bc coilz, JBR SSP, foglight tint, AP, Tial QR, TMIC w/tubes, AT HPFP, CS DP, DO METH stg1, 20% Tint, Black roof wrap and Side Engine Mounts
Cosmetic...

NoTraction 07-18-2012 07:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dsmluck (Post 1514184)
Cosmetic...

Parts off the last speed3 are in my garage. Like I said 3k lows are my only cosmetic mod.
Next mods in this order are HPFP, AP and coilz.. How do you like that Wrx btw.. I like the car but just not as much as my GenWon

dsmluck 07-18-2012 06:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NoTraction (Post 1514258)
Parts off the last speed3 are in my garage. Like I said 3k lows are my only cosmetic mod.
Next mods in this order are HPFP, AP and coilz.. How do you like that Wrx btw.. I like the car but just not as much as my GenWon

It boils down to this. The WRX is much cheaper to get power out of than the MS3. At about 350-380who you reach the "safe" limit of the engine and transmission on the car. The MS3 can go beyond that. With Front and Rear sways the WRX feels about the same as my old MS3. WRX is easier to corner for a noob like me because of AWD. Interior goes to the MS3. Launching obviously goes to the WRX. Both cars are great. Basically I chose the WRX because its bang for buck cannot be touched by the MS3 up to a point and I like AWD, always have.

As for reliability at sane power levels I would say its a toss up. Both cars have known weak spots but the reliability seems decent. I had issues with my k04 on the MS3 at 15k miles. The WRX has yet to have an issue.

Mchart 07-19-2012 12:50 AM

Fuck ya'll.

Ford Transit is more fastest and most furiously.

NoTraction 07-19-2012 11:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dsmluck (Post 1515392)
It boils down to this. The WRX is much cheaper to get power out of than the MS3. At about 350-380who you reach the "safe" limit of the engine and transmission on the car. The MS3 can go beyond that. With Front and Rear sways the WRX feels about the same as my old MS3. WRX is easier to corner for a noob like me because of AWD. Interior goes to the MS3. Launching obviously goes to the WRX. Both cars are great. Basically I chose the WRX because its bang for buck cannot be touched by the MS3 up to a point and I like AWD, always have.

As for reliability at sane power levels I would say its a toss up. Both cars have known weak spots but the reliability seems decent. I had issues with my k04 on the MS3 at 15k miles. The WRX has yet to have an issue.

Maybe I need to drive one with suspension mods. I always wanted one growing up. And fwd does get annoying at stoplights with the v8's in Michigan

bigx5murf 07-20-2012 04:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by breakfstincluded (Post 1504781)
http://wpc.556e.edgecastcdn.net/8055...vtaZ59_1_m.jpg


yeeeyyyaa netflix movie about wrx drag racing (:

Honestly, I didn't hate it.

Apparently we can do 10's in a subaru with a single parts trip to pep boys.

you didn't actually watch that movie did you? If you did, you'd known in a junk yard, there exists parts to turn a bugeyed wrx into a 06 sti. Also, to be fair, that finished sti was used on a street circuit race, very obviously fast forwarded while running against a skyline.

breakfstincluded 07-20-2012 04:17 PM

I must have bad memory, I don't remember a bugeye wrx, a street circuit race, junkyard or a skyline in that movie? Am I misunderstanding your question?

I remember his dad selling a buick GNX to fund the parts for his car, of which he got "hooked up" with by an old friend at pep boys.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 02:55 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.
vB.Sponsors

©Copyright 2008 ; 2019 Cymru Internet Services LLC | FYHN™ Autosports HQ
Ad Management plugin by RedTyger

Page generated in 0.21366 seconds with 11 queries